Skip to main content
Ottawa 2024
Times are shown in your local time zone GMT

Assessing student research

Workshop

Workshop

10:30 am

26 February 2024

M214

Session Program

Joanne Hart1
Di Eley2, Riitta Moller3, Wendy Hu4, Luke Finck5 and Christopher Williams5
1 University of Sydney, School of Medicine
2 The University of Queensland
3 Karolinska Institutet
4 Western Sydney University, School of Medicine
5 Vanderbilt University School of Medicine




Background
The development of research skills throughout the medical curriculum is globally acknowledged as fundamental to the practice of health professionals [1]. Such skills are not confined to the production of research outputs but are integral to the application of evidence- based practice [2]. A medical graduate is expected to have sufficient research competency to inform their professional practice. Worldwide, there is a diversity in how these research skills are integrated and assessed within medical programs, raising questions about the uniformity of research skill levels expected upon graduation [3]. This variability prompts an exploration of overarching research education learning objectives and how these are mapped to learning and assessment activities throughout the degree. 

This workshop will delve into the scope of teaching research skills within health profession curricula across various regions, including Australia, Sweden, and the USA. Discussions will cover a comparison of educational models, pedagogical strategies, and evaluative methods that aim to equip students with the necessary research skills upon their graduation. 


Why is the topic important for research and / or practice?
Medical schools worldwide lack a standardized core research curriculum. Given that graduates often seek post-graduate training abroad, it's vital to standardise research education. This could lead to globally recognised benchmarks for research and clinical competencies. 


Workshop format, including participant engagement methods. 
The workshop will be highly interactive. Each facilitator will introduce how research fits within their overall curriculum how it is assessed both at their particular institution and more generally in their country. 

This will be followed by a series of discussion starters and/or questions around the pros and cons of each as well as the similarities and differences between countries. 

Each facilitator will lead groups of participants to discuss their medical school context, the research skill curriculum and share their experiences of assessing research skills. 

Three main topics will be investigated: 
  • Explore contexts of research skills development – what is the focus for different medical programs? Does this differ across countries? 
  • Explore the research skills curriculum – what do graduates need to know? 
  • Explore the assessment practices for research education programs. 

There will be some flexibility about the topics depending on participant interests. 

Take-home messages
Through discussing international methodologies for teaching research curricula and their assessment, attendees can develop a deeper understanding of navigating research education and its assessment in diverse educational settings. This workshop aims to spark global dialogue and partnership on this important subject. 



References (maximum three) 

  • 1. Laidlaw, A., et al., Developing research skills in medical students: AMEE Guide No 69. Med Teach, 2012. 34. 

  • 2. Watson, H. R and Burr, S. Research skills in medical education. MedEdPublish, 2018. 7:151. 

  • 3. Lee, M.G.Y., W.C.Y. Hu, and J.L.C. Bilszta, Determining expected research skills of medical students on graduation: a systematic review. Medical Science Educator, 2020. 30. 

Joanne Hart1
Di Eley2, Riitta Moller3, Patrick Hu4 and Stephanie Moore-Lotridge4
1 University of Sydney, School of Medicine
2 The University of Queensland
3 Karolinska Institutet
4 Vanderbilt University School of Medicine 



Background
The importance of evidence-based practice underpinned by research principles is accepted internationally as essential and standard in medical programs. Graduates in medicine and health professions are expected to employ evidence-based skills in their practice and be, at minimum, research literate to do so. Indeed, this topic has been the subject of an AMEE guide; “Developing research skills in medical students: AMEE Guide No. 69”.1 There are various models delivering research skills content in the wider curricula though it is acknowledged as being unclear what research skills, and the depth of these skills, are expected at graduation. This lack of clarity invites a variety of taught skills and likewise the assessment of same across medical schools globally.2,3 This workshop will explore the range and depth of research skills taught and approaches to their assessment across three countries, Australia, Sweden and the USA. 


Why is the topic important for research and / or practice?
The acknowledged challenge is that a set curriculum of research skills is lacking across medical schools, and while this is understandable on an international scale it also occurs locally. This topic is important because it will contribute to an international awareness of what research skills are considered key for equipping students for practice and may lead to an international core research curriculum and benchmarking appropriate assessment methods, research, and generic skills. 


Workshop format
The workshop will be highly interactive. Each facilitator will introduce how research fits within their overall curriculum how it is assessed both at their particular institution and more generally in their country. 

This will be followed by a series of discussion starters and/or questions around the pros and cons of each as well as the similarities and differences between countries. 

Each facilitator will lead groups of participants to discuss their medical school context, the research skill curriculum and share their experiences of assessing research skills. 

The main topics to be investigated: 
  • Explore contexts of research skills development – the different delivery methods and focus for different medical programs. 
  • Explore the research skills curriculum – what is taught and how. 
  • Explore how research can serve as a platform for mentorship and a deeper understanding of the clinic. 
  • Explore the assessment practices for research skills. 

There will be some flexibility about the topics depending on participant interests. Who should participate? 

  • Academic or clinical staff involved in assessing research skills or capabilities. 
  • Researchers or clinicians supervising research projects and scholarly concentrations. 
  • New supervisor or supervisors-to-be for students’ research projects, or research skills teaching. 

Students of all medical and health science degrees interested in research and how research skill development is taught and assessed. 


Level of workshop:
Intermediate 


Take-home messages and workshop outcomes
By sharing the various research curricula, its assessment, from different countries, participants may gain a greater appreciation of how to deal with the complexities of research education and its assessment within their own learning and teaching environment. We aim for this workshop to initiate an international discussion and collaboration on this important topic. 


References (maximum three)
Up to three references 

  1. Laidlaw A, Aiton J, Struthers J Guild S (2012) Developing research skills in medical students: AMEE Guide No. 69, Medical Teacher, 34:9, 754-771 

  2. Lee MGY, Hu W, Bilszta J. Determining Expected Research Skills of Medical Students on Graduation: A Systematic Review. Med Sci Edu 2020; 30: 1465-1479 

  3. Murdoch-Eaton D, Whittle S. Generic skills in medical education: developing the tools for successful lifelong learning. Med Educ 2012; 46: 120-128.